Nov 25, 2025

Is It Worth Buying a Certified Used Car? An In-Depth Guide from Sunset Hills Subaru

When deciding on your next vehicle in the St. Louis, MO area, especially around communities like Maplewood, Crestwood, and Richmond Heights, you might wonder if purchasing a certified pre-owned (CPO) car is the right choice. At Sunset Hills Subaru, located at 10100 Watson Rd, Sunset Hills, MO 63127, we understand how important it is to find a vehicle that combines reliability, safety, and value. Whether you’re commuting through Fenton, exploring the outdoors near Valley Park, or driving through Chesterfield, a certified Subaru offers peace of mind with its thorough inspection and manufacturer-backed warranties. If you want to learn more or talk directly to our team, please call us at (314) 476-9638.

Table of Contents


Understanding Certified Pre-Owned Cars: What Sets Them Apart

Certified Pre-Owned vehicles are more than just used cars—they represent a higher standard of quality and reliability. At Sunset Hills Subaru, we ensure each CPO Subaru undergoes a comprehensive inspection process, performed by manufacturer-trained technicians who examine every critical component of the vehicle. This process typically involves over 100 checkpoints covering mechanical systems, body condition, and safety features. For drivers in nearby areas like Webster Groves and Glendale, this extensive evaluation means a car that’s ready for Missouri’s diverse weather and road conditions.

One of the defining features of CPO vehicles is the inclusion of a manufacturer-backed warranty, often extending coverage beyond what you’d find with standard used cars. For example, Subaru’s CPO program includes a 7-year/100,000-mile limited powertrain warranty plus a 2-year/24,000-mile comprehensive warranty from the date of purchase. This coverage reassures families in communities like Ladue and Maryland Heights that their vehicle is protected against unexpected repairs, providing substantial savings compared to out-of-pocket expenses on non-certified options.

Additionally, certified vehicles come with a full vehicle history report, documenting previous ownership, service records, and any reported accidents. This transparency is particularly valuable for buyers from St. Charles or Twin Oaks who want to avoid surprises and understand exactly what they’re getting. When contrasted with typical used cars, which might have unknown histories or incomplete maintenance records, CPO cars stand out for their reliability and peace of mind.

For those who prioritize safety and technology, certified Subarus often include factory updates and features like EyeSight® driver assist technology—a suite of safety enhancements designed to help avoid collisions and improve driver confidence. Whether you’re navigating the busy routes of Sappington or taking weekend trips towards Fenton, these features provide added assurance that your vehicle supports your family’s well-being.


Preowned vs. Certified Used: Key Differences Explained

The distinction between a typical preowned vehicle and a certified used car largely comes down to inspection rigor, warranty coverage, and overall assurance. While all certified cars are preowned, not every preowned vehicle qualifies for certification. In areas like Concord and Oakland, buyers often see many used cars that haven’t undergone the stringent checks required for certification, which can lead to varying reliability and maintenance histories.

Regular preowned vehicles at Sunset Hills Subaru’s Used Vehicle Inventory are inspected to meet our quality standards, but they do not receive the extended manufacturer warranty or the thorough multi-point inspection that CPO cars do. These vehicles can be excellent choices for value-focused buyers who may want to invest in an independent inspection or who are comfortable with limited warranty protections.

Certified vehicles, on the other hand, must meet strict criteria including:

  • Mileage limits (usually under 60,000 miles)
  • Accident-free or limited accident history
  • No outstanding recalls or major mechanical issues
  • Passing a detailed inspection covering engine, transmission, brakes, tires, and more

Because of these requirements, certified used cars generally command higher prices. However, this premium is offset by the added security of warranties, roadside assistance, and manufacturer support. For example, Subaru’s CPO program includes 24/7 Subaru Roadside Assistance covering services like flat tire changes and lockout help, exclusive benefits that are especially reassuring during Missouri’s winter months for drivers around Chesterfield and Richmond Heights.

In comparison, a non-certified preowned vehicle may require you to purchase separate extended warranties or rely on limited dealer guarantees. This difference can influence long-term ownership costs, especially in areas with variable road conditions like Glendale or Valley Park.


Benefits of Choosing an Approved Used Car at Sunset Hills Subaru

Approved used cars, particularly those certified by manufacturers like Subaru, deliver multiple advantages that make them an appealing option for families and professionals in communities such as Maplewood and Webster Groves. Beyond the rigorous inspection and warranty benefits, these vehicles come with:

  • Comprehensive Vehicle History Reports: Every certified Subaru at Sunset Hills undergoes a detailed review to confirm clean titles, no major accidents, and proper maintenance records, providing a transparent buying experience.
  • Access to Financing Options: Unlike many private sellers of preowned vehicles, our dealership offers a variety of financing solutions tailored to fit your budget, making the purchase process smoother for buyers in Ladue and surrounding suburbs.
  • Lower Mileage and Newer Models: Approved used vehicles tend to be newer with less wear and tear, often equipped with the latest safety and tech features like Apple CarPlay® and Android Auto™ to keep families connected on the go.
  • Included Roadside Assistance: Subaru’s CPO program provides complimentary roadside assistance, which is invaluable when traveling in more rural areas such as Twin Oaks or Fenton, offering peace of mind for unexpected situations.
  • Special Service and Parts Offers: To keep your vehicle running smoothly, Sunset Hills Subaru invites you to Schedule Service and Diagnostics with our expert technicians who use genuine Subaru parts available through Find Subaru Parts. Take advantage of our Current Service and Parts Specials for cost-effective maintenance.

For those wondering about the balance between price and value, the investment in a certified vehicle often pays off with fewer unexpected repairs and greater resale value, making it a practical choice for families in neighborhoods like Sappington and Concord.


Is Buying a Certified Used Car a Smart Decision for You?

Determining if a certified used car fits your needs depends on several personal and practical factors. For residents of Richmond Heights, St. Charles, and Oakland, the decision often comes down to weighing upfront cost against long-term reliability and peace of mind.

Certified cars tend to cost more initially—sometimes hundreds or thousands of dollars above comparable used cars. However, this premium includes benefits that mitigate risks such as expensive repairs, hidden vehicle history issues, or safety concerns. For example, a family commuting from Richmond Heights might value the fact that a certified Subaru Outback comes with EyeSight® technology and a warranty that helps protect against costly engine problems down the line.

If you’re considering a used vehicle but want to avoid the steep depreciation that new vehicles experience, certified used cars offer a middle ground. They provide many of the features and protections of new cars but at a lower price point. This makes them ideal for buyers from Glendale or Lakeshire who want reliability without paying full MSRP.

Additionally, the flexibility of financing with certified vehicles can make budgeting easier compared to private sales, where cash purchases are often the norm. Buyers can explore our Current New Car Specials and New Subaru Inventory to compare options, or browse our Used Vehicle Inventory for certified models.

If you’re unsure, we recommend scheduling a no-pressure test drive at our dealership to experience firsthand the comfort, technology, and safety that certified Subarus provide. Our team is happy to answer questions and help you evaluate your options for your lifestyle, whether you’re traveling around Chesterfield or commuting from Valley Park.


Finding Your Certified Subaru and Maintaining It for Years

At Sunset Hills Subaru, we make it simple to find the certified pre-owned Subaru that fits your family’s needs. Our certified vehicles come from a carefully curated selection, including popular models like the Subaru Forester, Outback, and Crosstrek—known for their standard all-wheel drive and fuel efficiency, perfect for Missouri’s changing seasons. Explore our Certified Pre-Owned Inventory online anytime from the comfort of your home in Twin Oaks or Webster Groves.

Once you’ve chosen your vehicle, maintaining it is crucial to preserving its value and reliability. We encourage you to Schedule Service and Diagnostics with our factory-trained technicians at 10100 Watson Rd, Sunset Hills, MO 63127. Our team uses genuine Subaru parts, ensuring your vehicle continues to perform at its best. Whether you need routine oil changes, brake pad replacements, or more extensive repairs, our service department is equipped to handle it efficiently.

If you’re considering upgrading your current vehicle, use our convenient tool to Get your value trade and see how much your trade-in is worth toward your next Subaru.

For owners wanting to personalize their Subaru, we also offer a range of accessories designed for practicality and style, such as all-weather floor liners, roof racks, and cargo organizers, helping you tailor your vehicle to your active lifestyle in communities like Maplewood and Fenton.


Choosing a certified used Subaru from Sunset Hills Subaru means embracing a vehicle that balances quality, safety, and value, tailored for the local needs of Missouri drivers. Whether your priority is the advanced safety of EyeSight® driver assist or the convenience of comprehensive roadside assistance, our certified vehicles offer a smart solution for families and professionals alike. Visit us or explore our inventories online to find your next Subaru today.


© 2025 Sunset Hills Subaru