Aug 26, 2025

What Kind of Tires Does Subaru Recommend? Comprehensive Guide for Subaru Owners in Sunset Hills, MO

When it comes to maintaining optimal performance, safety, and longevity of your Subaru, selecting the right tires is crucial. Whether you drive a Subaru Forester through the streets of Maryland Heights or navigate snowy roads near Glendale, MO, understanding Subaru’s tire recommendations ensures your vehicle operates at peak efficiency. At Sunset Hills Subaru, we are dedicated to guiding you with expert advice, quality parts, and professional maintenance services. For any tire or maintenance needs, please call us at (314) 476-9638 or visit our dealership at 10100 Watson Rd, Sunset Hills, MO 63127.

Table of Contents

Subaru equips its vehicles primarily with all-season tires designed to offer balanced performance across various weather conditions. These tires deliver dependable traction on dry, wet, and mildly snowy roads, ideal for drivers in areas like Valley Park and Ladue where winters are moderate. However, Subaru also advises drivers in regions with frequent or severe snow to consider dedicated winter tires for enhanced grip and safety.

The tire categories recommended for Subaru include:

  • All-Season Tires: Versatile for year-round driving with a compromise between winter traction and summer performance.
  • Winter Tires: Designed with softer rubber compounds and aggressive tread patterns for icy and snowy conditions, crucial for communities like Webster Groves and Creve Coeur.
  • All-Weather Tires: Hybrid tires that handle a wider temperature range, offering better snow traction than all-season tires but not fully replacing winter tires for harsh climates.
  • Performance Tires: Available on sportier models like the Subaru WRX and BRZ for enhanced handling and responsiveness.

Subaru’s AWD system performs best when all four tires have similar specifications and tread conditions, which leads to the importance of the next section.

Why Subaru Requires Four New Tires Simultaneously

Subaru’s Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system is engineered for consistent power distribution and enhanced traction, but this precision requires tire uniformity. Here’s why replacing all four tires together is essential:

  • Avoiding Drivetrain Strain: Different tire diameters or tread depths cause wheels to rotate at varying speeds, forcing the AWD system to compensate continually, which accelerates wear on the center differential, transfer case, and transmission.
  • Maintaining Traction and Stability: Uniform tires ensure balanced traction across all wheels, critical for maintaining vehicle stability on wet, icy, or uneven surfaces prevalent in Richmond Heights or Fenton.
  • Manufacturer Tolerance: Subaru specifies a maximum tread depth difference — often within 2/32 of an inch — to prevent drivetrain damage.

If replacing four tires at once isn’t feasible, Subaru recommends closely matching new tires to the existing ones in brand, model, size, and tread depth. In some cases, professional tire shaving can equalize tread depths, but this requires expert evaluation.

Consequences of Using Different Tires on a Subaru

Using mismatched tires on a Subaru can lead to serious mechanical and safety concerns:

  • Increased Drivetrain Wear: Unequal tire sizes or tread patterns cause the AWD system to work harder, resulting in premature failure of drivetrain components.
  • Handling and Safety Risks: Tires with different traction capabilities can confuse the vehicle’s traction control systems, reducing stability and increasing the risk of loss of control, especially in slippery conditions around St Charles or Twin Oaks.
  • Reduced Fuel Efficiency: The AWD system expends more energy compensating for mismatched tires, which leads to greater fuel consumption.

Always consult your Subaru owner’s manual or a qualified technician at Schedule Service and Diagnostics to ensure proper tire compatibility.

Top Tire Brands Recommended for Subaru Vehicles

Through extensive testing and Subaru’s own quality standards, the following tire manufacturers are highly recommended for Subaru owners:

  • Michelin: Known for exceptional grip, tread longevity, and overall performance. Models like the Michelin CrossClimate2 all-weather tire and X-Ice Snow winter tire are favored for their versatility and safety.
  • Continental: Offers innovative tread designs and durable compounds, excelling in all-season and all-terrain tires like the TerrainContact A/T.
  • Goodyear: Provides durable, high-performance tires such as the Assurance MaxLife and WinterCommand Ultra designed for longevity and winter traction.
  • Bridgestone: Renowned for their winter traction and quiet ride, with options like the Blizzak WS90 tailored for severe weather.
  • Yokohama & Pirelli: Deliver excellent performance in both on-road comfort and off-road capabilities, particularly for models like the Subaru Crosstrek.

When considering tires, Subaru owners in Sunset Hills and nearby communities can trust our dealership for expert recommendations based on local climate and terrain.

Understanding Subaru Tire Costs and Lifespan

The cost of Subaru tires varies by type and performance category:

  • Standard All-Season Tires: Generally priced between $150 and $350 per tire, balancing affordability with reliable year-round performance.
  • High-Performance and Winter Tires: Premium tires can exceed $500 per tire, reflecting advanced compounds and tread technologies designed for extreme conditions.

Expect an average tire lifespan of approximately 50,000 miles under typical driving conditions around Oakland or Crestwood. Lifespan depends heavily on driving habits, road surfaces, and maintenance practices such as rotation and proper inflation.

Our service center at Sunset Hills Subaru regularly offers tire inspections and rotations to help maximize tire life. Check out our Current Service and Parts Specials for ways to save on maintenance.

Best Winter and All-Weather Tires for Subaru

For regions with snowy winters like St Louis or Lakeshire, winter tires notably improve safety and control. Top recommendations include:

  • Michelin X-Ice Snow: Features Flex-Ice compound and micro-pumps for superior ice traction.
  • Bridgestone Blizzak WS90: Utilizes multicell compounds and 3D sipes for snow and ice grip.
  • Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5: Arctic Grip Crystals for extreme winter conditions.

For all-weather versatility, tires like the Michelin CrossClimate2 and Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady 2 offer enhanced traction in wet and light snow without the need for seasonal changes.

Tire Recommendations for Popular Subaru Models

Each Subaru model has specific tire sizes and requirements:

  • Subaru BRZ: Optimal tire sizes include P215/45R17 or P215/40R18, emphasizing performance and handling.
  • Subaru Forester: Commonly fitted with P225/55R18 or P225/60R17 tires, balancing comfort and capability.
  • Subaru Ascent: Uses larger tires like P245/50R20 or P245/60R18 for SUV-grade stability and traction.
  • Subaru Crosstrek: Recommended tires include the Michelin CrossClimate 2 for all-season use, Continental TerrainContact A/T for off-road adventures, and Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 for winter driving.

To explore new Subaru models with the correct tire fitments, browse our New Subaru Inventory or consider certified options in our Used Vehicle Inventory.

Maintaining Your Subaru Tires for Optimal Performance

Proper tire care extends safety and tire life. Key maintenance tips include:

  • Regular Tire Pressure Checks: Tires lose roughly 1 PSI monthly, so monthly inflation checks are essential.
  • Tire Rotations: Recommended every 5,000 miles to promote even tread wear.
  • Inspections: Look for uneven wear, cracks, punctures, or bulges.
  • Wheel Balancing & Alignment: Helps prevent vibration and uneven tire wear.

Schedule your next tire maintenance with our expert technicians at Sunset Hills Subaru Service Department to keep your Subaru driving smoothly and safely.

Service and Parts Support at Sunset Hills Subaru

Our dealership at 10100 Watson Rd, Sunset Hills, MO 63127 offers comprehensive support for all your Subaru tire and maintenance needs:

For personalized assistance or to schedule tire service, please Schedule Service and Diagnostics or call our team at (314) 476-9638.


Choosing the right tires is fundamental to maximizing your Subaru’s outstanding capabilities in every season and terrain. With expert guidance and quality products at Sunset Hills Subaru, you’re always equipped for a safe, comfortable, and reliable ride throughout Missouri’s variable weather.