Sunset Hills Subaru

Saved
Call 314-476-9712 Directions
«
»

How reliable are Subarus?

Sep 12, 2025

How reliable are Subarus?

For drivers in Sunset Hills, MO, and surrounding communities like Webster Groves, Chesterfield, and Richmond Heights, choosing a dependable vehicle is essential. Subaru has built a formidable reputation for reliability, safety, and long-term ownership satisfaction. If you’ve ever wondered, “Where is Subaru ranked in reliability?” or which Subaru models have the fewest problems, this detailed guide from Sunset Hills Subaru will provide the insights you need.

Whether you’re considering a new purchase or exploring reliable used options, this article will thoroughly cover Subaru’s reliability standing in 2025, model-specific dependability, maintenance considerations, and how Subaru compares to other brands. If you have questions or want to explore our extensive inventories, feel free to call us at (314) 476-9638 or visit us at 10100 Watson Rd, Sunset Hills, MO 63127.

Table of Contents

Subaru’s Reliability Ranking in 2025: Industry-Leading Performance

Subaru has achieved a remarkable milestone in 2025 by being ranked the #1 most reliable car brand by Consumer Reports. This ranking reflects Subaru’s consistent delivery of vehicles that excel in durability, safety, and owner satisfaction. For drivers in areas like Maryland Heights, MO, and Glendale, MO, this means peace of mind knowing they drive a vehicle built to last.

Consumer Reports scores Subaru with a reliability rating of 68 out of 100, leading well-known competitors such as Lexus, Toyota, and Honda. Subaru’s high ranking is attributed to its conservative engineering approach, which emphasizes the use of proven components rather than untested new technologies. This strategy minimizes the risk of unexpected issues and enhances long-term vehicle dependability.

J.D. Power’s recent evaluations also affirm Subaru’s reliability, with models like the Outback earning strong scores (82/100). These accolades reinforce Subaru’s place as a top choice for drivers seeking trustworthy transportation in cities like Chesterfield and Sappington, MO.

For those ready to explore the latest Subaru lineup, our New Subaru Inventory in Sunset Hills offers the full range of reliable models, including the Forester, Crosstrek, and Ascent.

Which Subaru Models Have the Least Problems?

When considering which Subaru has the least amount of problems, certain models stand out for their proven track record:

  • 2025 Subaru Forester: Known for its rugged durability and lasting performance, the Forester boasts a predicted reliability score that consistently places it among the best compact SUVs. It’s ideal for families in Valley Park, MO, looking for a vehicle that can handle both city streets and weekend adventures.


  • 2025 Subaru Crosstrek: This subcompact SUV combines fuel efficiency with robust AWD capability. It experiences fewer mechanical issues than many competitors, making it a favorite for drivers in Creve Coeur, MO, and nearby.


  • 2025 Subaru Outback: The Outback is a standout for versatility and longevity, often surpassing 200,000 miles when well maintained. Its spacious interior and strong safety features make it a popular choice among drivers in Richmond Heights and Ladue.


Other reliable models include the Legacy sedan, the Ascent midsize SUV, and the sporty BRZ, each delivering dependable service for different lifestyle needs.

Visitors to Sunset Hills Subaru can browse these models in detail through our dedicated pages like the New Subaru Forester Inventory or New Subaru Crosstrek Inventory.

Key Factors That Make Subaru Reliable or Unreliable

Subaru’s reliability is largely driven by several core factors that impact vehicle longevity and performance:

  1. High-Quality Components and Shared Platforms: Subaru’s engineering focuses on using robust, well-tested parts—especially its signature boxer engines and Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system. This consistency across models helps reduce failures and simplifies maintenance.


  2. Simple and Practical Designs: Subaru vehicles tend to avoid overly complex electronics and experimental technologies, which lowers the risk of malfunction. This pragmatic design ethos benefits drivers in areas like Concord and Twin Oaks, MO, by offering dependable daily transportation.


  3. Consistent Quality Control: Rigorous manufacturing standards ensure that each Subaru meets strict durability criteria, reducing the likelihood of early mechanical problems.


On the other hand, Subaru’s less reliable aspects have been associated with the electric Solterra model, which shares its platform with Toyota’s bZ4X and is still in early production stages. Some owners have experienced issues related to new electric vehicle technology, which is gradually improving.

For maintenance, Subaru owners in St. Louis and Maplewood, MO, appreciate the availability of genuine Subaru parts to keep their vehicles in top shape. Sunset Hills Subaru’s Parts Department offers certified components, ensuring repairs uphold vehicle reliability.

Best Years for Used Subaru Purchases

If you prefer buying a pre-owned Subaru, knowing which model years offer the best reliability is crucial for long-term satisfaction. Industry experts and customer feedback converge on these top picks:

  • 2014 and newer Subaru Outback: Praised for its versatility and durability, this generation features improvements in drivetrain and safety systems.


  • 2016 and newer Subaru Forester: Upgraded for better fuel efficiency and stronger reliability, the Forester remains a standout compact SUV.


  • 2018 and newer Subaru Crosstrek: Known for excellent fuel economy and AWD performance, this model is increasingly popular in urban and suburban areas alike.


  • 2015 and newer Subaru Legacy: A solid choice for sedan enthusiasts seeking a dependable all-weather vehicle.


  • 2019 and newer Subaru Ascent: The three-row SUV designed for families, combining space with Subaru’s hallmark reliability.


Explore the Used Vehicle Inventory at Sunset Hills Subaru to find certified pre-owned options with detailed maintenance histories and warranties.

Subaru vs Toyota: Which Is More Dependable?

Toyota has long been synonymous with reliability, but Subaru has recently edged ahead in several key areas. Both brands excel in building vehicles that last and maintain value, yet subtle differences guide buyers depending on their priorities.

  • Overall Reliability Rankings: Consumer Reports awarded Subaru the top spot for 2024 and 2025, slightly surpassing Toyota. Subaru scored 68 out of 100, while Toyota earned 62, reflecting Subaru’s consistent reliability across its lineup.


  • Long-Term Durability: Toyota’s hybrid powertrains are legendary for durability, often exceeding 300,000 miles with minimal repairs. Subaru’s AWD and boxer engines provide excellent all-weather capability but may require more frequent maintenance.


  • Maintenance Costs: Toyota generally has lower routine maintenance costs, but Subaru’s repair costs are competitive. Both offer extensive dealer networks near areas like St Charles, MO, and Crestwood, MO, easing access to service.


  • Driving Experience: Subaru’s symmetrical AWD and low center of gravity provide superior handling in challenging conditions, ideal for drivers in Fenton and Lakeshire, MO. Toyota focuses on fuel efficiency and smooth rides.


Ultimately, if your priority is rugged capability paired with strong reliability, Subaru is an excellent choice. For buyers seeking proven hybrid tech and low maintenance, Toyota remains a top contender.

Are Subarus Expensive to Repair?

Subarus are generally affordable to maintain and repair, especially when regular servicing is followed:

  • Routine Maintenance: Oil changes, tire rotations, and brake service are comparable in cost to other midsize SUVs and sedans. These services are readily available at Sunset Hills Subaru’s Service Department with certified technicians.


  • Common Repairs: Parts like oxygen sensors, wheel bearings, and brake components typically cost between $300 and $500 for replacement.


  • Major Repairs: While less frequent, repairs such as CVT transmission issues or head gasket replacements can be more costly, sometimes running into thousands of dollars. Proper maintenance helps mitigate these risks.


  • All-Wheel Drive System: Subaru’s AWD adds some complexity but also reduces wear on other drivetrain components, potentially offsetting repair costs.


Scheduling regular service with Sunset Hills Subaru ensures your vehicle stays in prime condition. Take advantage of our current Service and Parts Specials to keep maintenance affordable.

Do Subarus Hold Their Value Well?

Subaru vehicles are renowned for strong resale value, especially models with standard AWD and excellent reliability:

  • Key Drivers of Resale Value: Subaru’s reputation for reliability, safety, and ruggedness creates sustained demand in the used market. Brand loyalty is high, with many owners returning to purchase another Subaru.


  • Popular Models for Resale: Forester, Outback, and Crosstrek consistently perform well in depreciation studies, retaining a higher percentage of their original value over 3-5 years compared to many competitors.


  • Market Trends: In regions like Ladue and Oakland, MO, the demand for reliable AWD vehicles keeps used Subaru prices strong.


If you’re considering trading in your vehicle, use our convenient Get your value trade tool to discover its current worth.

Is Subaru Rated Reliable by Consumer Reports?

Consumer Reports not only ranks Subaru as the most reliable brand overall for 2025 but also praises specific models:

  • Seven Subaru vehicles, including the Outback, Forester, Crosstrek, and Ascent, earned Recommended status.


  • Subaru’s reliability stems from shared dependable components, such as the boxer engine and symmetrical AWD, which reduce new design risks.


  • The Solterra EV is the sole model with below-average reliability, reflecting early electric vehicle challenges.


For more detailed reviews and reliability data, consider Consumer Reports as an authoritative source confirming Subaru’s standing.

Do Subarus Require Special Gasoline?

Most Subaru models, including the Forester, Outback, and Crosstrek, run efficiently on regular 87-octane unleaded gasoline, making fuel costs manageable for drivers in Sunset Hills and nearby areas like Maplewood and Crestwood.

High-performance models such as the WRX and BRZ require premium fuel (91 or 93 octane) to achieve optimal performance and prevent engine knocking, especially important for spirited driving.

Additionally, Subaru recommends using TOP TIER detergent gasoline to maintain engine cleanliness and fuel efficiency. Avoid ethanol blends higher than E10 to protect your engine’s longevity.

How Does Subaru Reliability Compare to Honda?

Subaru and Honda are both leaders in reliability, but subtle differences exist:

  • J.D. Power’s recent studies show Subaru with 198 problems per 100 vehicles compared to Honda’s 206, giving Subaru a slight edge.


  • Consumer Reports ratings place Subaru’s predicted reliability at 69 versus Honda’s 70, indicating very close performance.


  • Subaru’s AWD system offers advantages in all-weather handling, while Honda models often excel in fuel efficiency and maintenance costs.


For buyers in Sappington and Valley Park, MO, these differences can guide the choice based on lifestyle needs.

Understanding Subaru’s Reputation in the Automotive Market

Subaru enjoys a strong reputation fueled by:

  • Safety Excellence: Consistently high scores from IIHS and NHTSA, with advanced features like EyeSight Driver Assist.


  • Longevity: Many Subarus exceed 200,000 miles with routine care.


  • Community Loyalty: A dedicated owner base in Sunset Hills and beyond often chooses Subaru repeatedly, fostering a community of enthusiasts.


At Sunset Hills Subaru, we invite you to join this community by browsing our New Subaru Inventory or Used Subaru Inventory, and experience Subaru’s renowned reliability firsthand.

Your Next Step Toward Reliable Subaru Ownership

Ready to experience Subaru’s renowned reliability yourself? Contact Sunset Hills Subaru at (314) 476-9638 or visit us at 10100 Watson Rd, Sunset Hills, MO 63127.

Whether you want to explore our new Subaru inventory or browse quality options in our used vehicle inventory, our knowledgeable team is here to guide you.

Don’t forget to schedule your routine maintenance or diagnostics appointment with our expert technicians through our Schedule Service and Diagnostics page to keep your Subaru running like new. If you’re considering trading your current vehicle, get an instant appraisal with our Get your value trade tool.

For genuine parts and accessories that maintain your Subaru’s quality, visit our Find Subaru Parts department.

Explore current offers in our Current New Car Specials and Service and Parts Specials to maximize your value.

Copyright © 2025 Sunset Hills Subaru

Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »

Connect with us

Forester | Sunset Hills Subaru in Sunset Hills MO
Outback | Sunset Hills Subaru in Sunset Hills MO
WRX | Sunset Hills Subaru in Sunset Hills MO
Solterra | Sunset Hills Subaru in Sunset Hills MO
Ascent | Sunset Hills Subaru in Sunset Hills MO
Crosstrek | Sunset Hills Subaru in Sunset Hills MO