Subaru Crosstrek vs Legacy: Which Is Better for Drivers in Sunset Hills, MO?

Subaru Crosstrek vs Legacy: Which Is Better for Drivers in Sunset Hills, MO?

When deciding between the Subaru Crosstrek and Subaru Legacy, many drivers in Sunset Hills, MO, and surrounding communities like Chesterfield, Fenton, and Crestwood are faced with a choice between two very different vehicles designed for distinct lifestyles. Whether you prioritize the versatility and ruggedness of a compact SUV or the refined comfort and efficiency of a midsize sedan, understanding the full scope of what each Subaru model offers is essential. At 10100 Watson Rd, Sunset Hills, MO 63127, (314) 476-9638, our team at Sunset Hills Subaru is ready to guide you through every detail, helping you make the best choice for your driving needs.

Below is a comprehensive guide to the strengths, challenges, and latest updates about these two Subaru favorites, including what the future holds for the Legacy model and why the Crosstrek continues to captivate adventurous drivers across the St. Louis metro area.

Table of Contents

• Comparison of Subaru Crosstrek and Legacy – Explore the key differences in design, performance, and utility between these two models to see which aligns with your lifestyle.
• What Is Replacing the Subaru Legacy? – Learn about Subaru’s strategic shift away from sedans and what it means for Legacy fans in Missouri.
• Is the Subaru Crosstrek Worth It? – Dive into owner feedback, performance metrics, and practical benefits that make the Crosstrek a top choice near Webster Groves and Ladue.
• Pros and Cons of the Subaru Legacy – Understand the advantages and limitations of the Legacy to help set realistic expectations.
• Rivals and Comparisons: Subaru Legacy vs Competitors – See how the Legacy stacks up against other midsize sedans popular in the St. Charles and Maryland Heights areas.
• Top Benefits of the Subaru Crosstrek – Discover why this compact SUV is beloved for its capability, tech, and economy.
• Longevity and Maintenance of the Subaru Legacy – Review detailed insights into the Legacy’s durability and how to maximize its lifespan.
• Is the Subaru Crosstrek a Smooth Ride? – Analyze ride comfort and handling for Crosstrek owners navigating the roads of Fenton and Valley Park.
• Subaru Legacy Discontinuation Explained – Get up to date on the official end of Legacy production and what alternatives Sunset Hills drivers can consider.
• Maintenance and Service Resources at Sunset Hills Subaru – Learn about expert services, parts availability, and trade-in options to keep your Subaru running strong.

---

Comparison of Subaru Crosstrek and Legacy

Selecting between the Subaru Crosstrek and the Subaru Legacy largely depends on your driving habits, cargo needs, and lifestyle demands. Both vehicles come equipped with Subaru’s hallmark Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive, which ensures confident handling in Missouri’s variable weather, including snow in nearby Twin Oaks and rain in Richmond Heights.

Performance and Powertrain

• Crosstrek: The 2025 model features two engine options—a 2.0-liter four-cylinder producing 152 horsepower and a more powerful 2.5-liter BOXER engine generating 182 horsepower. The availability of a higher ground clearance (8.7 to 9.3 inches depending on trim) and the Wilderness trim’s off-road enhancements make it ideal for those who venture beyond paved roads.
• Legacy: The sedan offers a 2.5-liter naturally aspirated four-cylinder engine standard, with a turbocharged 2.4-liter option in higher trims delivering up to 260 hp. While it excels in smooth highway cruising around Glendale and Maplewood, its lower ground clearance and sedan profile limit off-road potential.

Interior Space and Utility

• Crosstrek: Offers 19.9 cubic feet of cargo space behind the rear seats, expandable to over 54 cubic feet with seats folded down, accommodating sporting gear or large loads common in outdoor activities around Valley Park and Webster Groves.
• Legacy: Prioritizes passenger comfort with spacious front and rear legroom (42.8 inches front, 39.5 inches rear), making it perfect for family commutes or city driving in Ladue and Crestwood. Cargo space is smaller but sufficient for everyday needs.

Technology and Safety

Both models come equipped with Subaru’s EyeSight Driver Assist Technology, including adaptive cruise control, pre-collision braking, and lane-keeping assist. The Crosstrek, especially in Premium and above trims, features an 11.6-inch touchscreen with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration. The Legacy offers similar tech but adds refinements like DriverFocus and optional premium audio systems.

Real-World Example

A driver based in Creve Coeur who commutes daily but enjoys weekend hiking trips might prefer the Crosstrek for its off-road capability and cargo flexibility. Conversely, a commuter from Oakland or Richmond Heights who prioritizes highway comfort and fuel efficiency would find the Legacy sedan better suited to their needs.

---

What Is Replacing the Subaru Legacy?

With shifting consumer preferences favoring SUVs and crossovers, Subaru announced in April 2024 that the Subaru Legacy will be discontinued after the 2025 model year. This decision aligns with the declining sales of sedans nationwide, including in the St. Louis region.

Subaru’s Strategic Focus

• SUV and EV Emphasis: Subaru plans to expand its electric vehicle lineup, aiming for eight EV models by 2028, while doubling down on popular SUVs like the Outback, Forester, and Ascent.
• Legacy’s Role and Outback Continuation: The Outback, which shares the Legacy’s platform but offers SUV versatility, will continue to serve customers seeking crossover functionality.
• No Direct Replacement: There is no announced sedan replacement for the Legacy, signaling Subaru’s commitment to SUVs and electrification.

Impact for Sunset Hills Drivers

For those in Sunset Hills and nearby St Charles and Twin Oaks, the Legacy’s discontinuation means it’s a final opportunity to own a brand-new Legacy, available now at Sunset Hills Subaru’s New Subaru Legacy Inventory. Our dealership team can assist with exploring alternatives, such as the Subaru Outback or Crosstrek.

---

Is the Subaru Crosstrek Worth It?

The 2025 Subaru Crosstrek has earned a reputation among drivers in Sunset Hills and surrounding communities for combining all-weather capability with daily usability. However, like any vehicle, it presents a mix of strengths and challenges.

Owner Perspectives and Reviews

• Many appreciate the Crosstrek’s standard all-wheel drive, making it reliable on wet or snowy roads common in Lakeshire and Sappington.
• The fuel economy is strong, with EPA estimates around 29 mpg combined, which aligns well with city and highway driving around St Louis.
• Some owners note road noise and a somewhat slow infotainment system as points for improvement. Still, the user-friendly interface and connectivity options like wireless Apple CarPlay receive praise.

Practical Benefits

• Off-road readiness: The Wilderness trim boosts ground clearance to 9.3 inches, adds skid plates, and upgrades suspension for serious outdoor excursions.
• Comfort and Space: Elevated seating position and roomy cabin make it comfortable for families commuting in Webster Groves.
• Cost to Drive: Estimated ownership costs remain competitive, especially when factoring in Subaru’s renowned AWD system and resale value.

Dealer Support and Specials

At Sunset Hills Subaru, you can explore the full lineup of Crosstrek trims, including the popular Premium and Wilderness models. Don’t miss our Current New Car Specials to find great opportunities. For maintenance, Schedule Service and Diagnostics to keep your Crosstrek in peak condition.

---

Pros and Cons of the Subaru Legacy

The Legacy offers a distinct driving experience as a sedan, with notable strengths and some limitations.

Advantages

• Safety: Equipped with Subaru EyeSight, it boasts top-tier crash test ratings.
• All-Wheel Drive: Standard on all trims, a rarity in the midsize sedan class.
• Spacious Cabin: Generous legroom and headroom for passengers.
• Refined Ride: Smooth highway cruising, making it ideal for longer trips from Creve Coeur to St Charles.

Disadvantages

• No Manual Transmission: The lack of a stick shift option may disappoint driving enthusiasts.
• Underpowered Base Engine: The standard 2.5-liter engine feels sluggish compared to the turbocharged option.
• Driving Dynamics: Some find the ride somewhat uninspiring, especially in lower trims.

For those interested in a Legacy, our New Subaru Legacy Inventory at Sunset Hills Subaru offers a variety of trims to fit your preferences.

---

Rivals and Comparisons: Subaru Legacy vs Competitors

In the crowded midsize sedan segment, the Subaru Legacy competes with models such as the Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, Ford Fusion, and Nissan Altima—popular choices in the Missouri market.

Key Differentiators for the Legacy

• Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive: Unlike many rivals, the Legacy includes AWD as standard, offering better traction and safety on Missouri roads.
• Safety Features: Subaru’s EyeSight technology is standard, while competitors often reserve these features for higher trims.
• Resale Value: Legacy holds its value well, a key consideration for buyers in Sunset Hills and Chesterfield.

Areas Where Competitors Excel

• Hybrid Options: Models like the Camry and Sonata offer hybrid powertrains, appealing to eco-conscious drivers.
• Performance Variants: Some rivals provide sportier trims with more aggressive driving dynamics.
• Interior Refinement: Certain competitors may have more luxurious interiors in base trims.

For a hands-on comparison, visit Sunset Hills Subaru to test drive the Legacy and explore our Used Vehicle Inventory for competitive options.

---

Top Benefits of the Subaru Crosstrek

The Crosstrek’s growing popularity stems from a blend of rugged capability, efficiency, and modern amenities.

Rugged Design and Durability

• High ground clearance (up to 9.3 inches)
• Protective body cladding and reinforced chassis suited for off-road use near Fenton and Valley Park.

Advanced All-Wheel Drive

• Symmetrical AWD delivers consistent traction on Missouri’s wet and icy roads.
• X-Mode optimizes traction on slippery surfaces like snow or gravel.

Efficient BOXER Engine

• 2.5-liter engine offers 182 hp with optimal fuel economy (up to 29 mpg highway).
• Low center of gravity enhances handling and stability.

Versatile Cargo and Interior

• 55.3 cubic feet of cargo space with rear seats folded.
• Seating for five with flexible 60/40 split rear seats.

Safety and Technology

• EyeSight Driver Assist with adaptive cruise control and pre-collision braking.
• 11.6-inch touchscreen infotainment with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.

Explore the latest New Subaru Crosstrek Inventory at Sunset Hills Subaru and check out our Current Service and Parts Specials to keep your vehicle running at its best.

---

Longevity and Maintenance of the Subaru Legacy

Subaru Legacy owners in Sunset Hills and beyond benefit from a vehicle known for durability and low maintenance costs.

Lifespan Expectations

• Many Legacy vehicles surpass 200,000 miles with routine care.
• Rust-resistant construction and reliable CVT transmissions contribute to long-term value.

Maintenance Tips

• Follow scheduled services: oil changes every 5,000 miles, brake inspections, and timing belt replacements as recommended.
• Use genuine Subaru parts for repairs to maintain warranty and performance; visit our Find Subaru Parts page.

Service Support

Sunset Hills Subaru offers expert maintenance tailored to Subaru vehicles; Schedule Service and Diagnostics with our certified technicians.

---

Is the Subaru Crosstrek a Smooth Ride?

Drivers in communities like Richmond Heights and Maplewood often praise the Crosstrek for its balance between rugged capability and everyday comfort.

Ride and Handling

• The elevated ground clearance and symmetrical AWD system smooth out bumps and rough patches typical of rural routes or urban potholes.
• CVT transmission provides seamless acceleration, although some note mild engine noise at highway speeds.

Interior Comfort

• Spacious cabin with high roofline and elevated seating position enhance visibility and comfort.
• User-friendly infotainment with large touchscreen and intuitive controls.

The Crosstrek offers an ideal blend for Missouri drivers seeking a vehicle that performs confidently on both city streets and outdoor trails.

---

Subaru Legacy Discontinuation Explained

The end of the Subaru Legacy marks a significant shift for fans of traditional sedans in the St. Louis area.

Timeline and Impact

• Legacy production ends after the 2025 model year.
• Final chance to purchase new Legacy models at Sunset Hills Subaru.

Alternatives and Future Focus

• Subaru’s emphasis will be on SUVs and electrified vehicles.
• The Outback remains the go-to Subaru for those seeking wagon-style versatility.

Visit Sunset Hills Subaru’s New Subaru Legacy Inventory now to explore last-year models.

---

Maintenance and Service Resources at Sunset Hills Subaru

Keeping your Subaru Crosstrek or Legacy in optimal condition is easy with the expert services available in Sunset Hills.

Service Department

• Schedule routine maintenance or diagnostics through our Schedule Service and Diagnostics page.
• Certified technicians trained in Subaru care provide reliable repairs and service.

Parts and Accessories

• Genuine OEM parts ensure longevity and performance; order any needed components via our Find Subaru Parts portal.

Trade-In and Specials

• Wondering about your current vehicle’s value? Use our Get your value trade tool.
• Check out Current New Car Specials and Current Service and Parts Specials for savings opportunities.

---

Sunset Hills Subaru at 10100 Watson Rd, Sunset Hills, MO 63127 is your trusted local source for Subaru vehicles and service. Call us at (314) 476-9638 or visit our showroom to discover which Subaru best fits your lifestyle and driving needs. Explore our New Subaru Inventory and Used Vehicle Inventory today.

Tags: New Subaru, New Subaru SUV
Posted in 2025 Subaru Crosstrek | No Comments »